I really appreciate all the feedback I get when I post here. It means a lot to me. I also appreciate when people ask the hard questions because it gives me the opportunity to think about my journey and my intents for the things that I do and the choices I make. This blog is here to share my story but to also learn from each other. I'm very open and honest and I don't mind when people ask questions. Sometimes I write things here that I realize aren't quite as clear as I would like them to be so when you ask questions, it gives me the chance to clarify and explain things further.
I've had a few people off the blog ask some of the same things that have been asked in comments so I'll try to answer them as best as I can in this post. I hope that those of you that have commented don't mind if I quote some parts of the comments so as to put my answers in the proper context.
"I fear that the surgery is a band-aid, and though I think it could be a valuable tool for you, until you can cope with your BED I wonder how this will help."
"I think it might be better to take some time to work on the issues in therapy, and maybe have the surgery at a later date when you know you're in a good position to be able to follow the food restrictions afterwards without going overboard."
"I'm a bit concerned about how the lap band and the eating disorder will interact."
These are really great points to bring up. The Bariatric Surgery Clinic in my area has a lot of pre-op requirements that have to be met before surgery can take place. There is typically a 6-7 month wait from the time you start with the program until the surgery takes place. During this time, there are meetings with support groups, the dietician, testing outside of the clinic, meetings with the surgeon and nurses, a full psych evaluation, therapy, and counseling. There is also a minimum of 5% of body weight that has to be lost (sometimes more, depending on the procedure and your starting weight) pre-op.
I have actually been in therapy for a year and a half with one therapist and for 6 months now with a psychologist that specializes in eating disorders. Both of them are working with me on different aspects of learning to cope with BED and to make behavior modifications. One of the things that my psychologist (the one that specializes in eating disorders) said, as well as my primary physician, is that therapy is going to be key in any behavioral modification program, even more so than the part a surgery plays into modification. All three feel that with where I'm at now, the Lap-band will be used in conjuction with a LOT of therapy, dietary changes, and a behavioral modification plan as a tool to achieve success not only in weight loss, but primarily in learning to manage and overcome my BED.
One of the requirements for being able to have the Lap-band surgery is that I would need to follow nutritional guidlines and undergo therapy. One of the reasons the clinic requires a full psych evaluation and behavioral modifcation to be put into place before the surgery is to make sure that their patients are mentally able to handle the surgery and the life-style changes reguired for it to be successful. The paperwork from the clinic makes it very clear that acceptance into the bariatric surgery program is not a guarantee of surgery. There is a lot that has to come together in order to get the green light for surgery. If I'm clearly not ready to handle the commitments of the procedure and the psychologist at the clinic doesn't feel that I'm ready, I won't get the go-ahead.
There are many different types of therapy, aversion therapy being one of them. Traditionally, aversion therapy was quite brutal with its electrical shock therapy and such. Today, though, there are different ways to use this therapy while still being ethical. In fact, aversion therapy is a commonly used therapy in treating OCD and other compulsive disorders. Think of the Lap-band as a modern version of aversion therapy. When the Lap-band is first put into place, bingeing is pretty near impossible and trying to binge becomes painful and unpleasant with vomiting, etc.
"I believe that in a previous post you said that you would not treat cancer with radiation or surgery, so I am wondering what the difference is for you here."
Another great point to bring up. I don't put the Lap-band and chemo/radiation on the same level. For me, using chemo/radiation would be too high of a risk with introducing something into my system that has the potential to kill off not only cancerous cells but also the good cells. My personal opinion, from watching friends and loved ones go through these processes, is that they have great potential to do harm. I know there are many sides to the chemo/radiation do-or-don't-do argument, but this is where I stand on it. I watched my grandfather die a slow and painful death while going through two years of chemo and radiation and I have watched it unfold in other people, as well. That's just not something I'm willing to do to my body. Surgery, however, I see a little differently. If there is a highly positive prognosis of surgery being able to remove cancer without harming the rest of the body further, I would be in favor of it. In other words, if I had breast cancer and the doctor told me that it would be easy to remove and with very few complications, I would most likely consider it. If the doctor told me that the surgery had a lot of complications and health risks, as well as the possibility that removing the cancer could potentially spread it if something went wrong, that I would rather find alternative routes to combat the cancer. These thought processes will probably not make sense to some, but they are something I've felt passionate about for many years. When it comes to the Lap-band, the complications and risks are very low. There are no chemicals being spread through my body to kill cancer cells. It is something that can be removed (unlike the chemo and radiation once it enters your body). These are where the differences lie for me.
"From an outside perspective, which you can take or leave with no offense to me, it seems that the overwhelming problem you face is the compulsive disorder... not your weight."
I think it's very difficult to separate these two issues. Binge Eating Disoder (BED), which is a compulsive disorder, often causes obesity (there are some cases in which it doesn't because of other factors). Those with BED not only struggle with complusion, but they also struggle with the weight caused by it. Compulsive disorders have their own set of issues, but BED also usually carries with it depression, guilt, frustration, and anger due to the weight issues. The obesity that often happens as a result of BED causes a lack of energy, self-esteem, and mobility. From helpguide.org:
The binge eating cycle
Binge eating may be comforting for a brief moment, but then reality sets back in, along with regret and self-loathing. Binge eating often leads to weight gain and obesity, which only reinforces compulsive eating. The worse a binge eater feels about themself and their appearance, the more they use food to cope. It becomes a vicious cycle: eating to feel better, feeling even worse, and then turning back to food for relief.
It's also important to know that people with BED don't always binge eat due to stress or for comfort. They may eat simply because that is what they find the compulsion to do. Many bingers don't want to eat when they binge.
"Because from an outside perspective, you seem like an incredibly healthy woman- in mind, body and spirit."
I like to think of myself in this way, but the reality of it is that there is a part of me that doesn't feel any of that at times. There are parts of me that I'm just beginning to be comfortable in sharing and those are the parts that totally contradict being that "incredibly healthy woman- in mind, body and spirit." Just like everyone, I have those days that are hit-or-miss when it comes to feeling this way. For a long time, I've been quiet about my struggles and come across as that woman described above so I think it takes people by surprise when they see a part of me they're not used to.
"Also (I would be saying this on an earlier post, but I don't know if you see new comments on older posts), I really, really hope that you're bringing David along for some therapy sessions, or that you do so in the future."
As a heads up, I see every comment that's posted no matter when the blog post was made as they come to my email when you post them.
I really do want to take David to some of the therapy sessions provided by the bariatric surgery clinic. The psychologist that I see that specializes in eating disorders also wants to do some family therapy because we all, as a family, contribute to each others successes and shortfalls. There are many ways that I think David would benefit from going to my therapy sessions and I also feel that my kids would benefit, as well.
Wow.....I didn't realize that I was going to end up writing so much. Thanks, again, for the feedback and questions. I always welcome them.